Particularly independent positions after the Supreme Court ruling: five steps to reduce risk
The Norwegian Working Environment Act allows employees in leading or particularly independent positions to be exempted from the Act’s working time provisions, including the rules on maximum working hours and overtime pay. The exemptions have long been an established feature of Norwegian working life, and more than 10 % of all employees in Norway are currently exempted.
In many businesses, classification has been based on job title, salary level or flexible working hours, without a specific assessment of each individual position.
If a position has been incorrectly classified as particularly independent, the employee is entitled to overtime pay under the Act. Claims may extend up to three years back, and the business must also comply with the working time rules going forward. For businesses with many employees in such positions, the total exposure may be significant.
The Norwegian Supreme Court has now addressed the conditions for a particularly independent position for the first time. The Court unanimously held that a project manager in a construction company did not hold such a position. The exemption must be interpreted narrowly, and flexible working hours, significant responsibility and freedom in how tasks are performed are not sufficient in themselves. For a closer look at the Supreme Court’s assessment and the factors it emphasized, see our previous article here.
The ruling sets a stricter threshold than many businesses have applied. We expect employees and employee representatives to use the ruling to challenge existing practice.
The question is what employers should do now to reduce the risk.
- Map, quantify and prioritize
Start with an overview of which employees are currently classified as particularly independent, and on what basis. Prioritize the groups with the highest practical and legal risk, typically positions with substantial work beyond normal working hours.
- Review current routines and practice
Review both the written routines and guidelines and how the exception is applied in practice. Determine whether changes to current practice are necessary and possible.
- Assess positions individually
Each position must be assessed against the criteria set out in the ruling. One of the key questions is whether the employee genuinely controls their own workload (and by that their worktime), or whether deadlines or client expectations in practice determine how much work is required.
- Identify the right solution for each position
In some cases, the current classification may be maintained, either as is or with adjustments. Where this is not possible, other options are available. These may require changes to the role, the working time arrangements and/or the employment terms. The right solution will depend on the specific circumstances of each position.
- Follow up
Ensure that managers are trained in the new routines and that the board is informed of the measures implemented. The classification of each position should also be reviewed annually, as roles and working conditions may change over time.
